In Mauritania, recently, a 40-metre purse seiner of Turkish origin obtained a derogation to fish for small pelagics in a zone reserved for artisanal fishing, under the guise of experimental fishing.
In the last months, trawlers of Spanish origin, registered in Senegal, have received an experimental fishing temporary authorisation to fish Liberian deep-water shrimp, through the Senegal-Liberia bilateral agreement. In both cases, the vessels are fishing intensively in specific locations, causing concern about the impact of this fishing on fragile resources.
"Everyone understands what is meant by experimental fishing," explains the scientist Ad Corten, expert on small pelagics fisheries, "it is the use of commercial fishing vessels to explore the possibilities of a new fishery; that is, a fishery for a known species in a new area, or a fishery for a new species in a known area. Such an experiment should be small-scale and of limited duration to avoid negative effects on other species, or on the stock of the species under study. The experiment must be planned and closely controlled by scientists.” (Ed. Informal exchange, quoted with permission).
While there is no clear definition at the FAO level for this type of fishery, some regional fisheries organisations, such as the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CCAMLR), specify that experimental fisheries are fisheries for which it is necessary to collect sufficient information to assess the distribution, abundance and demography of the target species, thereby enabling the potential yield of the fishery to be estimated; to examine the potential impacts of the fishery on dependent and related species and to enable the Scientific Committee to formulate and provide advice on appropriate catch and effort levels and fishing gear.
Clearly, the aim of experimental fishing is scientific. But is it always so, like in the case of the Senegalese boats in Liberia?
The Senegal-Liberia Fishing Agreement
A fishing agreement was signed between Senegal and Liberia in 2019, allowing access of Senegalese artisanal, semi-industrial and industrial vessels to Liberian waters. For industrial fishing, the agreement includes access for 2,000 GRT (up to 5 trawlers of 250 GRT each).
The Liberia Fisheries Law of 2019 does not provide for experimental fishing, but only for research fishing for scientific purposes (Part 3 - section 10.24 Conditions for research fishing). This research fishing is subject to a series of conditions. Thus, any person requesting authorization to undertake this type of fishing must submit a detailed research plan for the duration of the fishing operation or related activities: "No research fishing authorization shall be issued without such a plan having been submitted to and approved by the Director General.” In addition, "each research fishing authorization shall be subject to the embarking of at least two Liberian scientists or observers for the duration of the research at the expense of the person to whom the authorization is granted.”
The results of the research and the raw data must be provided to the Director General within a specified time period in consultation with the researchers. The authorization must be consistent with any relevant fisheries management plan and the law also suggests that the authorization should be subject to "a requirement for the holder to undertake an environmental impact assessment of the research".
Experimental fishing is however mentioned in the protocol of the 2019 Senegal-Liberia bilateral agreement. Article 3.7 states that these fishing opportunities "shall be considered as experimental fishing until such time as the stock assessment makes it possible to know the potential. Observer coverage must be 100% for trawlers".
The retail price of Carabineros, the largest prawn in the world, can be up to 80USD per kilo, although it is difficult to estimate the free-on-board value. The amount paid by the operators to the Liberian government will depend on the captures declared. Photo by Luca D’Adezzio, used via Canva Pro.
In terms of fishing zone, the Liberian Fisheries and Aquaculture law clearly states the limit of the coastal exclusion zone, reserved for artisanal fishing, which is "up to a distance of 6 nautical miles from the baselines used to delimit the territorial sea". However, the same text allows, in section 4.3 on the inshore exclusion zone, "industrial shrimp, cephalopod and other vessels fishing for inshore species to trawl beyond 4 nautical miles".
Senegalese trawlers in Liberia: Intensive fishing …
Under the Senegal-Liberia Agreement, two Senegalese flagged trawlers, the SOKONE and the KANBAL III, belonging to the Senegalese company SOPERKA, which is part of the Grupo Pereira from Vigo (Spain), have received temporary authorization for experimental fishing in Liberian waters. These trawlers are bottom trawlers, each almost 40 metres long. Data collected on Global Fishing Watch show that they trawled extensively, on deep water reefs, in July and August 2021.
The KANBAL III was suspected in 2017 of reducing the opening of the meshes in the net, a technique that makes trawling less selective, although Senegalese authorities did not arrest the vessel in the end. Photo: from the Soperka website.
On 11 September 2021, a third vessel, EL AMINE, also part of the SOPERKA fleet, arrived from Dakar and began trawling on the same reef as KANBAL III.
...to be closely monitored, despite the lack of means
One would expect that vessels engaged in experimental fishing designed to gather information on the sustainability of the operation would themselves be committed to sustainability. One might wonder about the KANBAL III, which was singled out in 2017 because there were indications that the vessel had used a technique to reduce the opening of the meshes in the net, making its trawling even less selective. At the time, Senegalese authorities did not see fit to arrest the vessel, promising further investigations.
Another reason for concern is that, so far, neither the KANBAL III, the EL AMINE or the SOKONE have entered the port of Monrovia. Indeed, a good way for a country to control the catches made in its waters is to inspect the vessel upon its arrival in port. The conditions of the experimental fishing authorisation provide for this to be the case, unless the port in Liberia is not operational to receive the landing of catches taken by industrial fishing vessels. In that case, the license expressly states that the landing shall be made in Senegal.
But, on 27 September, the KANBAL III was landing in the port of … Abidjan. In the framework of a cooperation between Liberia and Côte d'Ivoire, facilitated by the Fisheries Committee for the West Central Gulf of Guinea (FCWC), a joint inspection of the KANBAL III was carried out in the port of Abidjan to verify that the vessel complied with the regulations and that the catches were in conformity with the report of the observers on board. This type of joint inspection, which remains exceptional, is to be applauded in order to prevent vessels from escaping the scrutiny of the inspectors of the country where they are fishing.
Economic benefits below expectations for Liberia
These powerful trawlers operate on the deepwater reefs off Greenville for a valuable resource, the deepwater red shrimp (known as Carabineros in Spain), the largest prawn in the world. The free-on-board value of Carabineros is difficult to estimate, but the retail price can be as high as $80 per kilo.
Under the Senegal-Liberia agreement, the operators of these trawlers, which do not land any catches in Monrovia, are required to pay 10 per cent of the ex-vessel value of the fish caught. The amount paid will depend on the catches declared by the captain and the values realized by the operators. It needs also to be noted that, thanks to the experimental fishing authorization they have, the operators avoid paying the 10% export tax that would be due if they had a regular license.
The only verification of catches is by a single observer on board, - which falls short of what the Liberian law requires for research fishing. In the absence of actual independent verification of catch reports, regardless of the port where the catch is offloaded, and with Liberia foregoing the export tax revenue, the economic benefits that can be realized by Liberia are probably below expectations for the exploitation of such high value resource.
This could change in the future, as on the 19th of October, Liberia signed a financing agreement with the World Bank for the Liberia Sustainable Management of Fisheries project, worth US$ 40 Million. Through this agreement, it is expected that the completion of the Mesurado Pier into an industrial port will allow more than 77 industrial fishing vessels to land their catches in Liberia. Madam Emma Metieh Glassco, Director general of the National Fisheries and Aquaculture Authority (NaFAA), said the three times expansion of the Mesurado Pier will lead to the creation of huge job opportunities for Liberia and Liberians, provide huge supply of fish on Liberian markets at a cheaper rate, reduce the net importation of fish.
However, for the time being, the multi-million dollars profits from the deepwater shrimp catches are almost entirely lost to Liberia.
Doubts about the scientific value of this experimental fishery
The methods of payment are not specified in the experimental fishing authorization. Moreover, in contravention of the conditions set for research fishing in Liberia, the operations of the trawlers targeting deep water shrimp have not been subject to a research plan, and thus the data to be collected is not defined. There is also no plan for communicating the results of the research, and there is no specification of the environmental impacts to be monitored in the license conditions.
In summary, the activities of these vessels in Liberian waters are not transparent, and it is highly unlikely that they will produce useful data for resource assessment.
Is the objective really to improve scientific knowledge of the targeted resources, or to find through this 'experimental fishing' a way to exploit their economic potential, by intensively fishing resources of high commercial value?
For Dr. Alassane Samba, fisheries scientist and former director of the Centre de Recherches Océanographiques de Dakar Thiaroye (CRODT) in Senegal, things are clear: "If experimental fishing is well conducted, it is with scientists who develop the program, execute it, analyze the data and publish the results with documented recommendations. If we go beyond that, it is organized pillaging". (Ed. Informal exchange, quoted with permission).
Banner photo: A beach in Monrovia, by blk24ga under Creative Commons licence.
A new study presented to the European Parliament Fisheries Committee outlined the strengths and weaknesses of the CFP and other EU policies in addressing current and future challenges in fisheries and aquaculture.